Kat's Film Reviews: The Magdalene Sisters

Tuesday, November 30, 2004

The Magdalene Sisters

These Magdalene Asylums in Ireland were set up to house and care for women (the Magdalene Sisters) who had borne children out of wedlock, or even women who seemed to be good bets for tempting men. Horrible things, these asylums, and not necessarily only because of the hard slave labor conditions, or the cruel attitudes of the nuns who ran these asylums. The horror of these places was that these women were separated from their babies and sent away by their families, in some cases for the rest of their lives. It is as if these women ceased to exist. That's certainly what the Church wanted, to weed out these women from general society. Problem is, they'd done nothing wrong. They hadn't killed, stolen or maimed anyone. They'd had a child out of wedlock, which is immoral and a mortal sin in the Catholic faith, but doesn't warrant someone being "disappeared" from society. Unfortunately, while the film shows us the cruelty of these places and the desperate measures some girls went to to try and escape, it doesn't tell us what happened to these asylums and why they were finally closed (the last one in 1996). Even the documentary that the film was based on, which is part of the DVD, doesn't address this. So, the film felt incomplete to me -- if this cruelty is the basis for the film, at least do us the favor of telling us why it stopped happening! Did the women who escaped or were released let the world know? Was there public outcry? Did those who ran these institutions finally discover the errors of their ways? Without this, it's just melodrama, and that's a pity.

year: 2002
length: 119 min.
rating: 3.0
IMDB link: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0318411/combined

¶ 11:45

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home